"Something is rotten in the state of Denmark." - Last Action Hero
As a brief aside, I know that the above quote is from Hamlet. But the linked video above is both hilarious and relevant in that it could be construed as an attack on one of the greatest and most elegant pieces of literature ever, much like my post today could be construed as an attack on the normally empirical and intelligent nature of Behind the Net. I'm mostly kidding(I hope), but bear with me on this one and we'll be in good shape. Today's experiment is analyzing skating patterns. Specifically, the skating patterns of Nicklas Lidstrom and Duncan Keith from the Detroit-Phoenix and Chicago-Toronto games on March 3rd.
Here are two images:
What you see in these images are two charts of skating patterns. If the names not been at the top in semi-readable handwriting and you were given a choice between which one of these charts, at face, is Nick Lidstrom and which one is Duncan Keith, chances are that your perception of them would be exactly what they are. Lidstrom is known as one of the most efficient skaters in the NHL and for having an almost eerie sense of positioning. Keith is the young dynamo who is probably my pick for the best all around skater in the NHL. Both of these shifts are about a minute long and they convey the different methods two Norris Trophy winners use in their craft. If you are wondering what these charts say, here's a helpful guide:
- E, for entry, is where the shift begins. This could be from the bench, as they are in these charts, or from where they begin on the faceoff, which you'll see on other charts. If the player stays out there for multiple whistles, I've included a break point and a start point for each consecutive event of play, using a different colored line on the same chart. Black is first, orange is second, green is third. Luckily this didn't happen too much, as it can start to get clunky. I might separate the charts by every whistle next time if these are too muddy. Let me know what you think!
- There was a bit of an evolution of the method, as you'll see. I did all of the Lidstrom shifts first. On his chart, the numbers are right through the line, while on Keith's charts his numbers are associated with dots on the line. I think the latter is a better method and I started doing that pretty early. So, try to overlook that.
- You may notice that there is a bit of a legend at the bottom. I tried to mark down every event that they took place in on their skating path. Keith's, you'll notice, has a GV- giveaway, a RP- receive pass, a DI- dump-in, a U- pickup of a loose puck, and a P- pass. I've also included the times for these as indicated on the game clock. The D on Lidstrom's chart is a dump-in. I forgot to put an I and I have these all edited down for size already. Forgive me.
- I was limited, especially in the Detroit game, by the camera. The dashed lines you see are a representation of a straight line between when the player leaves the view of the camera and when the player returns in view. I was really tempted to kind of just infer based on hockey knowledge but I decided against it because I think that leaves too much subjectivity. So, I put a straight dashed line between camera time. It's times like these when I actually wish I had access to the NBC Bridgestone Mazda Sponsored Star Cam.
- Keith is defending the left side of the chart, and Lidstrom is defending the right side of the chart.
- Finally, for disclosure of process, all of these were done similar to last week's pass charts on a Lenovo X60 Thinkpad tablet with a Wacom stylus pen.
Lidstrom, however, took a good solid two minute shift. The type of shift Mike Keenan got so upset at Alex Kovalev for taking that he repeatedly did not let Kovalev come off the ice for an entire period. Only Nick Lidstrom is no Alex Kovalev, and part of this was a power play. Still, I love that story. Anyways, Nick Lidstrom started out in his defensive zone, receiving a pass at 1, missing a breakout pass at 2, but the Red Wings gained possession anyway and got a power play. Starting off at 4 and working on the power play, you'll see that he stayed on his side, playing catch a little at 5 and 6, but then shifting down to the low side wall at 7 and receiving a pass, protecting the puck for a second, and then making a pass from 8 into the slot. I'll note that this was a goal by Johan Franzen. Fantastic. Now, not content to get off the ice, as it's only been a minute, he stayed on from 9, moved up and closed off the gap on a Coyotes forward trying to enter the zone and took the puck away and made a breakout pass. Happy with his reputation sealed as a two-way defenseman by getting an assist and a takeaway on the same two minute shift, he glided over to the bench.
So, like I said before, I'm not sure what to make of these charts. I think they contain less data than the pass charts I did lass week and are of less utility, but I still think it's an interesting exercise to do and it provides some pretty pictures. I don't think this is going to be a valid way to track events, so I think I'll probably stick with tracking the puck more. But, for kicks, here are the charts for the first period of both games, in two handy images (Keith's last shift is missing for size reasons).
As always, let me know what you think. All feedback is very much appreciated. If I was going to do this particular chart again, I was thinking about looking at Ovechkin's skating patterns from last year to this year- with Boudreau's new defensive system, is he staying further back at the expense of cherry picking?
Thanks for reading,