Comments / New

When did the NHL All-Star Game become a total joke?

I know I’m a month late on this, but the NBA’s joke of an All-Star Game made me wonder when the NHL All-Star game went off the rails. Certainly, offensive levels skyrocketed in the early 1980s:Asggpg_medium

We see the same thing happen in the shot department:

Asgspg_medium

And shooting percentage:

Asgshp_medium

Penalties present a slightly different and more interesting situation. In the 1960s, the Stanley Cup champion played the rest of the league – everybody knew each other and the champs had just beaten everyone on the other team. You can bet there was bad blood and a lot more hacking and slashing than usual – no fights, though; the last fight was in 1948 (Gordie Howe, of course) and technically in 1968 (Howe again, though roughing minors were assessed.) A larger league and an East-West game reduced the bad blood and led to a large drop in penalties even as the league itself got rougher. The drop in penalties and intensity went even further in the last decade as most All-Star Games featured zero penalties:

Asgppg_medium

It's not clear to me why All-Star Games suddenly became meaningless 30 years ago. Maybe nobody wanted to hit Wayne Gretzky? I don't think I've ever watched one of these no-hitting scrimmages, so I'm probably the wrong guy to ask.

Looking for an easy way to support Arctic Ice Hockey?
Use our Affiliate Link when shopping hockey merch this holiday season!

Talking Points